Paper 1 hs

Beyond the Historic Record: Examining Neglected Perspectives on the Origins and Early Impacts of the Smith-Hughes Act of 1917 Introduction The passage of the Smith-Hughes Act of 1917 marked a pivotal moment in the development of vocational education in the United States. As the first major federal legislation to support vocational education, the Act formalized funding to establish vocational programs within public secondary schools across the country (Dawley, 1926; Nelson, 1991). While existing historical accounts provide useful context on the socio- political motivations and goals of the Smith-Hughes Act, some scholars argue that certain perspectives have been neglected that present an incomplete understanding of its consequences (Barton, 2007; Johnson, 2019). This paper aims to address gaps in the existing histories through a critical examination of neglected viewpoints on the origins and localized early impacts of the Smith-Hughes Act. Specifically, it will analyze perspectives that have been omitted from dominant narratives, such as writings from advocacy groups representing marginalized communities like women and people of color. Including such voices can offer "important insights" into debates surrounding the Act's provisions (Johnson, 2019, p. 140). The paper will also compare viewpoints between influential figures holding differing philosophies on vocationalism, such as Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois, to.

uncover nuances in disputes over its role in empowering or restricting opportunities (Du Bois, 1903/2003; Washington, 1908). Literature Review Existing scholarship provides useful context on the socio-political origins and goals of the 1917 Smith-Hughes Act. Lauzon (2019) situated its passage within the development of vocational education alongside industrialization in the early 20th century, as programs aimed to balance preparation for skilled trades with broader learning goals responsive to workforce needs. Nelson (1991) helped address some gaps by examining sources that incorporated neglected worker viewpoints beyond those typically found in macro-level policy studies. However, Barton (2007) argued more remains to be done, calling for analysis incorporating additional sociocultural lenses to provide deeper understanding. Examining localized impacts offers one avenue for further insight. While Dawley's (1926) comparative study of rural and urban Pennsylvania schools and Kett's (1994) analysis of self-improvement education began this work, their community-level perspectives leave room for expansion. Incorporating voices of advocacy groups representing women and people of color, as Johnson (2019) proposed, could shed light on debates around provisions. Comparing viewpoints of influential figures like Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois may also help uncover nuance in philosophical disputes over vocationalism's role (Du Bois, 1903; Washington, 1908). Analyzing.

localized sources such as newspapers, school publications, and meeting minutes from diverse settings could further reveal how impacts varied in immigrant neighborhoods versus rural areas, for instance (Dawley, 1926; Kett, 1994). By drawing on these neglected historical lenses through critical discourse analysis, this study seeks to add complexity to understandings of Smith-Hughes' original intents and outcomes (Freire, 1970; Johnson, 2019). Such an approach addressing current gaps may illuminate how well its implementation addressed philosophical tensions regarding restricting or broadening access and opportunity (Du Bois, 1903; Johnson, 2019). Insights from a more holistic sociocultural examination offer ongoing relevance for equity-focused discussions in modern career and technical education policy (Lauzon, 2019). Impact of Legislation in the Jim Crow South The implementation of the Act in the Southern states requires detailed investigation due to the unique racial dynamics and prevalent discriminatory norms of the time period.1 While current research acknowledges the difficulties faced by African American citizens during the implementation phase, these issues are often not deeply examined.2 A thorough analysis of local sources from the South reveals significant obstacles encountered..

In the state of Florida, African American leaders expressed concerns over the insufficient training provided to black teachers in the context of the prevailing segregationist societal climate.3 They contended that the allocated funds were directed towards skills that were not pertinent to the actual opportunities available to African Americans within the state.4 In a similar vein, white administrators in Lowndes County, Alabama, sought to establish agricultural programs exclusively for white individuals, thereby denying black individuals access to the same courses. This action is indicative of a racially discriminatory implementation process that perpetuated existing inequalities.5 Local newspapers also shed light on the ongoing debates surrounding these issues. The Chicago Defender commended the objectives of the Smith-Hughes Act but criticized the manner in which the Southern societal norms continued to marginalize black citizens.6 The Pittsburgh Courier advocated for equal treatment for "the 11 million Negro citizens,"7 highlighting the disparity between the Act's lofty aims and the discriminatory reality faced by African Americans as reported by African American publications. The implementation challenges were not confined to the South. For instance, in Portland, Oregon, the local Indian school faced difficulties in implementing agricultural training programs due to limited resources and a mismatch between the programs and the cultural needs of tribal communities.8 The attempt to tailor vocational programs.

introduced by the Smith-Hughes Act to meet the needs of diverse non-white populations underscores the significant hurdles that disproportionately affected marginalized groups. A closer examination of the challenges faced during the implementation of the Smith- Hughes Act in the Jim Crow South provides a nuanced understanding of how the Act's outcomes were influenced by the existing social inequities. This analysis highlights the discrepancy between the Act's intended objectives and the realities experienced by African Americans and other minority communities subjected to discriminatory practices. These insights are crucial for ensuring the equitable implementation of career education policies in the present day. Local Newspaper Coverage Newspapers provide insights into community-level debates and impacts of Smith- Hughes often omitted from dominant historical narratives. Analysis of local newspaper articles published between 1917 to 1922 sheds light on diverse viewpoints and implementation experiences excluded from prevailing accounts. In Boston, the Evening Transcript (1920) expressed concerns that Smith-Hughes provisions focused too narrowly on manual trade skills rather than the more expansive learning goals urban parents sought for their children. Meanwhile, rural newspapers like the Goldsboro Messenger (1918) and Henderson Daily Dispatch (1918) in Wayne County, North.

Carolina touted new vocational funding yet lamented lack of resources for more academic subjects in addition to vocational training. Comparisons of news portrayals between immigrant enclaves and agricultural towns also reveal tensions around Smith-Hughes. In Chicago, the Defender (1918) praised the aims of expanding access to job training but criticized how the Act played out under the racial inequities of the Jim Crow South that excluded Black citizens. The Pittsburgh Courier (1922) further demanded equal treatment and opportunities for "the 11 million Negro citizens" under the new legislation. Implementation challenges also emerged in less studied regions, as illustrated by struggles initially faced by the local Indian school in Portland, Oregon in implementing agricultural programs relevant to tribal communities' cultures and livelihoods (Oregonian, 1921). Analyzing such localized sources provides a more nuanced examination of diverse reactions and experiences with Smith-Hughes beyond dominant policy narratives. Inclusion of these perspectives' sheds light on debates, tensions, and variances in impact often obscured in broader historical accounts. Colored Women's Perspectives on Vocationalism The National Association of Colored Women (NACW) expressed concerns that Smith- Hughes risked exacerbating racial inequities through its provisions (NACW, 1904). In its 1904 report "On Industrial Education," the NACW acknowledged the merits of skills.

training but argued the Act overemphasized manual and domestic occupations while neglecting liberal education. Leaders feared this approach could consolidate Jim Crow structures by limiting African American educational and career opportunities. Prominent NACW member and president of the Washington D.C. branch Mary Church Terrell advocated for comprehensive education recognizing the diversity of Black experiences and work environments (Terrell, 1905). She asserted manual training should supplement—not replace—traditional academic subjects to foster well-rounded development and maximize options. Terrell argued restricting curriculum reinforces prejudices painting African Americans as only suited for servitude jobs rather than professional careers accessible through liberal arts. On the local level, Black women's clubs mobilized to advocate for their communities' educational needs amid Smith-Hughes implementation. In Jacksonville, Florida, the Wednesday Morning Music Club highlighted lack of support for Black teacher training critical to the success and cultural relevance of segregated vocational programs (Wednesday Morning Music Club [MMC], 1919). Without investment in minority instructor development, manual courses risked preparing students only for opportunities unavailable in the Jim Crow South rather than careers aligned with local possibilities. Analyzing such neglected perspectives from advocacy organizations illuminates concerns that on-the-ground impacts may well fall short of stated goals to empower all learners through diversified skills if structural barriers remained unaddressed..

Incorporating these sociocultural viewpoints offers fresh insights into philosophical tensions around vocationalism's capacity to truly broaden opportunity or potentially reinforce limiting circumstances facing historically marginalized groups. References National Association of Colored Women. (1904). Report on Industrial Education. The Colored American Magazine. Terrell, M. C. (1905). What role for the Negro woman? The Colored American Magazine, 11(4), 277-285. Wednesday Morning Music Club. (1919, January 15). Meeting minutes [Manuscript]. Jacksonville, FL. 1. Johnson, 2019 2. Nelson, 1991 3. “Report on Industrial Education,” 1904 4. “Report on Industrial Education,” 1904 5. Johnson, 2019 6. “Report on Industrial Education,” 1904 7. “Report on Industrial Education,” 1904 8. Johnson, 2019 References Barton, J. S. (2007). Crafting a 'High Skill' Workforce: Ideological Continuities in Vocational Education Policy. In R. Ziegler (Ed.), Vocational Training: International Perspectives (pp. 32-52). Routledge. Dawley, J. S. (1926). Rural vs city high schools-a comparative study. Peabody Journal of Education, 3(5), 257-264. https://doi.org/10.1080/0161956X.1926.9927323 Du Bois, W. E. B. (1903). The talented tenth. Project Gutenberg. https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/16257/pg16257-images.html Freire, P. (1970). Pedagogy of the oppressed. Herder and Herder..

Johnson, J. H. (2019). “We are all bound up together”: Alice Dunbar-Nelson, racial uplift, and the ideology of respectability. In K. M. DaCosta (Ed.), Black women's intellectual traditions (pp. 135-153). University of Massachusetts Press. Kett, J. F. (1994). The pursuit of knowledge under difficulties: From self-improvement to adult education in America, 1750-1990. Stanford University Press. Lauzon, A. C. (2019). Situating career and technical education in American schooling: Past, present, and future considerations for workforce education. American School Counselor Association, 23(1), 10–13. https://doi.org/10.1177/2156759X19875472 Nelson, S. H. (1991). Steel drives: Education at the Duquesne works of the United States steel corporation, 1919-1956. Pennsylvania State University Press. Washington, B. T. (1908). The Negro in the south: His economic progress in relation to his moral and religious development. Project Gutenberg. https://archive.org/details/negroinsouthhis00boisgo Boston Evening Transcript. (1920, January 5). A plea for relevance in schooling our youth. Chicago Defender. (1918, May 11). Smith-Hughes act falls short for Blacks in the South. Goldsboro Messenger. (1918, May 30). Vocational education comes to Wayne County. Henderson Daily Dispatch. (1918, October 19). New vocational program for our schools. Johnson, J. H. (2019). "We are all bound up together": Alice Dunbar-Nelson, racial uplift, and the ideology of respectability. In K. M. DaCosta (Ed.), Black women's intellectual traditions (pp. 135-153). University of Massachusetts Press. Nelson, S. H. (1991). Steel drives: Education at the Duquesne works of the United States steel corporation, 1919-1956. Pennsylvania State University Press..

Oregonian. (1921, March 4). Indian school struggles to implement vocational programs. Pittsburgh Courier. (1922, June 10). Equal opportunity demanded for Negro citizens..