Countering : Kaguya's dimensions are universal sized

Published on Slideshow
Static slideshow
Download PDF version
Download PDF version
Embed video
Share video
Ask about this video

Scene 1 (0s)

[Audio] A finite distance is not the same as all finite distances. We see Sasuke running towards Sakura and Madara notes that his teleportation jutsu has a limit to what distance it can travel. That is what Sasuke means by a finite distance. Just substitute A finite distance with 25 metres for example and it would work fine but it doesn't necessarily mean that distance between two dimensions are infinite..

Scene 2 (28s)

[Audio] This statement that it's a "vast" space is a mistranslation. Run it through any translator or jisho. It will always say it's a distant or a far away space..

Scene 3 (42s)

[Audio] Time-space =/= Space-time, the same way e-mail =/= maile. Time-space is not a word in English. It's a term added by the translator, the meaning of which we have to get from context. The translator explicitly shows a difference in usage of these terms :- "The time-space of space-time/ teleportation ninjutsu" (in the same sentence) The word time-space has been used interchangeably with space, dimension, world. Time-space cannot mean space-time, " space-time of space-time ninjutsu" is not used and makes less sense. Time-space = dimension. Whereas the nature of reality in the dimension can be explained by a different spacetime..

Scene 4 (1m 33s)

[Audio] Kaguya's dimensions are referred to jikukan twice (which refers to spacetime). However the use of space-time in Naruto rarely has to do with the ' 4th dimension'. For example, let's consider space-time ninjutsu. It works by the user marking the ' co-ordinates' and then warping a hole in the space time from Point A to Point B. But the thing to note here is that the user only moves across space, doesn't move across time. This is more like a 'space' ninjutsu rather than a space-time ninjutsu. To have a 'consistent' co-ordinates in a different dimension, the dimension would need to be in the same space-time as the user's space-time, unless the co-ordinates are higher dimensional co-oridinates which give the positioning of multiple space-times, in which case, the user should be completely capable of moving across the 'time' axis, but they don't, meaning they are space co-ordinates, meaning the dimensions have the same space-time. In Naruto, space and space-time are used interchangibly and space-time has nothing to do with 4th dimension and generally only refers to the space ( 3d construct).

Scene 5 (2m 47s)

[Audio] Kaguya's dimensions are referred to as extremely distant by Obito. There cannot be a distance between space-times unless it's a 4D distance, in which case Sasuke's " 4D distance" should be finite as well. It's unlikely that Sasuke would talk about 3D distance and obito would talk about 4D distance. Even Limbo is referred to as a extremely distant, meaning they are part of the same space-time. This is also backed up when you see characters allegedly moving across space-times and still be consistent in time with each other. Jigen's dimension is stated to have the same time as the shinobi world. This cannot happen if they are different space-times, unless the 'time axis' is of the spacetimes of spacetimes which is unlikely..

Scene 6 (3m 38s)

[Audio] If Kaguya was capable of creating a space-time, that means she created all possible events (future and past), all of it. Space-time is not evolving thing. It's there, all of it. So, if Kaguya created ' ice' space-time, then she also created the events of her fight with Naruto/ Sasuke. So why would she create an event where she would lose against them? Why is she affected by the gravity ? Gravity is the bending of curved space time due to mass/ energy. It means that planet has higher force/pull than Kaguya herself which doesn't make sense for someone who created a space time and has that level of energy. Kaguya who apparently created space-time and all possible events created an event where she doesn't have 'enough time'. Kaguya who was going to create a space-time, cannot create an event where Sasuke doesn't use Amaterasu, meaning she isn't creating space-times when she is using Amenominaka or her dimensions don't have a different space-time..

Scene 7 (4m 47s)

[Audio] Code says that "unless you escape to another dimension, nearly everyone and everything will die". The above statement can only be true if the dimensions are different planets. The statement assumes they have a way to escape to another dimension, so "when did shinobi invent space-travel" is not an argument. Plus they can travel to moon and other planets with the gates that Amado has created to travel to different planets if they have ' co-ordinates' Light cannot escape from a space-time and we see light in kaguya's dimensions coming from stars, meaning they are not different space-times. The star is part of the same space-time as the planet. And as code already confirmed the planet and it's atmosphere is the dimension for the otsutsuki. It's hard to grasp but imagine a boundary of the dimension to be the planet's atmosphere. That is also consistent with Kakashi saying "If the orb becomes too big, we won't be able to come back".

Scene 8 (5m 51s)

[Audio] Sasuke's mangeykyo can't see universal ranges. If it's in his field of vision, then he can see it. It's also referring to Sharingan being able to see through illusion, otherwise there are things like sensory/ vision blockers that sharingan can't see. Doesn't mean those things are in another universe. Naruto wasn't able to sense Sasuke because the ice dimension wasn't connected to the desert dimension. The same way Naruto can't sense what's going on in Kamui dimension. Obito could sense sasuke from root dimension. Will continue the rest of the points in a separate video/show..