[Audio] Welcome to this research skills session – in this session, we will be discussing how to approach reading scientific articles using the IMRAD approach. But before we talk about what IMRAD is and how to use it, let's first talk about sources for scientific information that we may want to use in our research..
[Audio] We can divide the sources of our scientific information into two broad categories – primary and secondary sources. Primary sources generally take the form of original, new research that reports new findings, usually from either raw, unprocessed data, or from data that has been statistically processed. An example of this might be a study where we have measured the height of pupils at a local school, and we have done some statistical analyses, so that we can report for example the averages, minimums and maximums, and so on of this group. Usually, the authors of the source will use their own findings and attempt to place them in the context of the broader literature. When they do this successfully, they are able to give a scientific opinion on what they think their findings mean, and how this contributes to the scientific field. In the scientific literature, primary sources usually take on the form of research articles, published in academic journals. Secondary sources go further than just reporting findings and giving a limited opinion of a study's contribution to the field. These sources combine several primary sources, summarizes their main findings and then goes a step further to synthesise what the combined findings mean. Synthesis is a very important part of scientific research – it is the skill of connecting multiple sources of information to create new insights, arguments or conclusions, rather than just summarising each source individually. Secondary sources of information showcase this nicely. For example, if several studies are done to measure the height of pupils at different schools, each of those studies can only report their own statistics and discuss how they compare to the others. But, with a secondary source, the authors can now begin to see that some studies might have used different techniques for measuring (e.g. direct or from photographs), or that most of the studies have looked at high schoolers but only a few have looked at primary schoolers. From this, the authors can give some opinions on possible gaps in the literature – which methods work better than others, which ones need more testing, which samples have we not looked at sufficiently? From these questions, we can then begin to develop new studies to fill these gaps, and report their findings as primary sources. In the scientific literature, secondary sources usually take on the form of textbook chapters or sometimes review on a specific topic..
[Audio] We have to be a little careful when talking about academic articles, as there are many different kinds that sometimes serve very different purposes. Original research articles are the most common form – these are reports on the findings of a scientific study, usually with only one or two specific aims. An example of such a study would be the example we mentioned earlier of measuring the height of pupils at a local school. These articles are useful for many aspects of new studies, in that they can help identify an appropriate method to address a research problem, give data for comparison with new studies, and later also help interpret new results in the broader context though comparisons. The other example we mentioned earlier as a secondary source is the review article – this is usually written by an expert in a particular topic, and can either focus on giving details of the current state of the research on that particular topic, or highlighting where the research gaps and ongoing debates still are. These articles are most useful for reviewing basic theory on a topic (though not as extensively as what you would find in a textbook), and identifying potential gaps to research in new studies. The next type of article is the case study – these are common in medical and anatomical journals and usually focus on describing a specific single case of a particular variation, condition or disease. Recently, some scientific journals have decided not to publish individual case studies anymore, because they want to prioritize broader, generalizable research that boosts article and journal ratings. However, case studies do still hold value in fields such as medicine, where individual reports of very rare cases (as primary sources) might eventually be enough to allow synthesis into a secondary source that can highlight valuable similarities of such cases. Some journals have suggested that combining a case study with a systematic review of the related literature usually makes the article more acceptable for publication. The next article type is a technical note – a report that usually deals with either the method (how to do something) or methodology (theory of how to do the thing) in a practical context. In anatomy, for example, this could mean an article on a new dissection method or embalming process enhancement, or in physiology, it could mean an article outlining a new cell culture method or a motivation for an extra-cellular rather than intra-cellular approach. Because of the highly practical nature of their content, these articles tend to be much shorter than others, as the theory behind the content does not need to be explained in detail..
Overview of progress in field Solutions for specific problems Understanding of fundamental aspects Ideas for future research Support for own work.
INTRODUCTION. MATERIALS & METHODS. RESULTS. DISCUSSION.
WHY?. HOW?. WHAT?. SO?. IMRAD. Most common way articles are formatted: Introduction Materials & Methods Results Discussion (and Conclusion).
There is this problem… … we understand some parts of it BUT other parts need more investigation … one of these areas is this… and is important because… So what I did was… … and I found this… …which means… …and is important because we now know….
Function: Provides necessary background/ context (sometimes Lit review) Significance of research question What has been done? What needs to still be (re)done? Key players/works.
Elements to cover: State problem/ purpose Provide context to show importance Highlight major debates/gaps Study rationale and significance Deliminate boundaries Define key terms/ concepts (if needed) State aim/ hypothesis.
Function: Provides technical information of how study was done Plan of action to answer research questions Justification of chosen approach Link to existing methods.
Elements to cover: Study design Sample Variables Instruments Procedure Approvals Enough detail for another scientist to replicate experiment.
Use tables, figures, graphs to represent raw/ slightly processed data Translate data numbers to observation text.
Final sample Any changes to procedure. Outcomes of each experiment/ test Any “accidental” findings.
Function: Brings together Introduction and Results Answer research question Interpret results Explain meaning in context.
Elements to cover: Briefly recap salient results Explain immediate meaning Possible alternative interpretations Place in broader literature and society context Agree or disagree, reasons Strengths and limitations.
Function: Wrap up argument Inverse of Introduction (narrow to broad) Final chance to state importance of study Tie to broader context.
Elements to cover: Summarize main points Highlight importance and implications Explain how study has moved field forward Recommendations for future studies.
INTRODUCTION. MATERIALS & METHODS. RESULTS. DISCUSSION.
CLASS ACTIVITY. Using the Steyn & İşcan (1998) article: Mark characteristic features of the IMRAD format in the article Answer the questions from the Heard guide (pg 66) to create a Story summary of the article.
[image] 1. What is the central question? 2. Why is this question important? 3. What data are needed to answer this question? 4. What methods are used to get those data? 5. What analysis must be applied for the data to answer the central question? 6. What data were obtained? 7. What were the results of the analyses? 8. How did the analyses answer the central question? 9. What does this answer tell us about the broader field?.
INTRODUCTION. MATERIALS & METHODS. RESULTS. DISCUSSION.