Constraints, risk, & misunderstandings:

Published on
Embed video
Share video
Ask about this video

Scene 1 (0s)

Constraints, risk, & misunderstandings:. THE TRIPLE BIND THAT UNDERMINES PERSON-CENTRED CONTRACEPTIVE CARE.

Scene 2 (44s)

[Audio] Power imbalances remain in contraceptive care despite the focus on patient-centred care. In a recent study, providers endorsed patient-centred ideals but also had a strong emphasis on preventing unplanned pregnancies. This tension was illustrated by Gavin, who denounced coercion but advocated for postpartum LARC to be given earlier than clinical guidelines. To gain a better understanding, it is worth looking at what Gavin had to say..

Scene 3 (1m 14s)

[Audio] Gavin discussed choice and rejected coercion, however then declared that postpartum LARC should be provided earlier than indicated by clinical guidelines, which he labeled as midwives being 'proactive'. He communicated that while he holds power, he would never willingly witness or coerce someone into using contraception, as it is oppressive. Subsequently, we will review the research revelations that demonstrate patient-centred care is not a reality for most women..

Scene 4 (1m 43s)

[Audio] The quote "there are always going to be women who, get nervous—because of their social background, education level—they're not going to rock up and have their depo (injection) given three weeks later" highlights that person-centred care is not universally provided and is supported by other research. This demonstrates the importance of taking the necessary steps to create a successful business plan..

Scene 5 (2m 7s)

[Audio] Seeking to explore the challenges faced by contraceptive providers in their efforts to deliver quality care, this paper proposes that these competing influences form a ‘Triple Bind’ that undermines quality care and contributes to the persistence of power imbalances in healthcare. In order to gain further insight into this situation, we must evaluate the accounts of providers in the context of this Triple Bind, taking into account the tight constraints of time, resources, and expectations that are all at play..

Scene 6 (2m 37s)

[Audio] The aim of this paper is to explore the ways in which constraints, risk, and misunderstandings can lead to a triple bind that inhibits effective person-centred contraceptive care. Our research focuses on two countries, South Africa and Aotearoa New Zealand, to compare the ways in which constraints, risk, and misunderstandings affect contraceptive care. As we can see from the table, there are distinctions in both countries in terms of gender and 'race'. In South Africa, 92% of those surveyed were female and 81% were black; while in Aotearoa New Zealand, 90% were female and 63% were of Māori, Indigenous origin. For each country, there were also differences in the types of providers, with South Africa having a greater number of nurses and Aotearoa New Zealand having a greater number of Specialist practitioners. Our research seeks to provide insights into how these differences may play out in terms of constraints, risks, and misunderstandings that affect person-centred contraceptive care..

Scene 7 (3m 44s)

[Audio] Contraceptive care is a vital and delicate subject. Therefore, it is essential that it is provided with consideration for the individual. Sadly, numerous elements can make this onerous - from resource restrictions to associated risks and misconceptions. This paper explores the interrelation between these three aspects and how they form a triple bind that can obstruct individual-focused contraceptive care. This discussion is based on two particular contraceptive methods - Depo Provera injections and Jadelle implants - and examines the experiences of health care providers in both South Africa and New Zealand..

Scene 8 (4m 24s)

[Audio] Contraceptive care is an essential part of healthcare, one that should take into account a patient's needs and desires. Unfortunately, constraints such as limited resources, provider risk aversion, and language and cultural divides can cause issues with access to this care. This leads to a complex and difficult situation known as a triple bind, which can lead to patients being cut out of the decision-making process and their interests and preferences not being taken into account..

Scene 9 (4m 56s)

[Audio] Biomedicalisation has increasingly become the main approach to contraceptive care in modern times. Medical professionals are responsible for assessing risk and providing solutions to avert any potential risks, but they tend to overlook the individual's circumstances. This can lead to risk management decisions that are not tailored to the person's situation and preferences, which ultimately undermines personalised contraceptive care..

Scene 10 (5m 23s)

[Audio] Person-centred contraceptive care is essential for protecting women from risk. To properly assess risk, two aspects must be taken into account: capacity and reliability. Capacity assesses a person's ability to comprehend information, chances, and the results of their choices. Reliability, meanwhile, examines a person's ability to adhere to their decisions. Together, capacity and reliability form a thorough analysis that can help safeguard women from risk. When it comes to protecting women from risk in person-centred contraceptive care, it is important to consider both capacity and reliability. By considering a person's ability to understand information, opportunities, and the consequences of their decisions, as well as their capacity to remain consistent in their decisions, a comprehensive assessment can be made..

Scene 11 (6m 20s)

[Audio] Healthcare providers need to bear in mind the limitations, dangers and misconceptions associated with providing person-centred contraception care. Being aware of these issues and managing them accordingly can help us to provide better care for our clients. For instance, when dealing with teenage contraception, the reliability of taking medication must be considered. It has been observed that adolescents often forget to take the pill, thus increasing the likelihood of becoming pregnant. In light of this, methods such as injectable contraception are recommended, as they tend to be more reliable and effective over a longer period of time. Understanding all the aspects involved in creating contraception awareness and offering contraception care is essential in ensuring a secure and safe way of avoiding unwanted pregnancies..

Scene 12 (7m 12s)

[Audio] When it comes to person-centred contraceptive care, a 'triple bind' may be created from various sources, including constraints, misunderstandings, and the effects of risk. This paper examines how different discourses such as family planning, biomedical outcomes, and efficacy can influence this triple bind. Examining this information is important to ensure that person-centred contraceptive care is delivered..

Scene 13 (7m 39s)

[Audio] Contraceptive care is an essential part of healthcare, however it can often be restricted, contain risks and be misinterpreted. Therefore, to deliver the best possible care, we must build a comprehensive structure, just like we do with other medical treatments. This model will allow for shared decision making to be prioritized during contraceptive care, so patients are given the resources needed to make informed decisions and are supported throughout the process..

Scene 14 (8m 10s)

[Audio] When it comes to 'at risk' women, providers are often faced with a dilemma between their safety and convincing them to use lower-risk contraception such as Long-Acting Reversible Contraception (LARC). This paper looks into the complexities of this dilemma and advances understanding of how providers and other stakeholders can better navigate it. It examines the interactions between three key components - constraints, risk, and misunderstandings - and how they shape the provision of person-centred contraceptive care. It demonstrates how these three factors may be reinforcing a 'triple bind' that contributes to the difficulties of providing adequate care to 'at risk' women. The paper ultimately provides an insight into how providers can better navigate these challenges to ensure women's safety and autonomy are always respected..

Scene 15 (9m 1s)

[Audio] Confronted with constraints, risks, and misunderstandings of their own contraceptive care, a patient can be placed in a triple bind. This can lead to irrational decisions, due to the lack of information provided, as well as a lack of resources to obtain reliable information. This can further result in the patient being regarded as a "victim" of their own choices if they are unable to make an informed decision because of their lack of knowledge..

Scene 16 (9m 29s)

[Audio] Contraceptive care can present a range of challenges. From risks to constraints and misunderstandings, a combination of these issues can lead to a triple bind that hinders person-centred care. For instance, opinionated views can supersede the professional advice being given, even if it is clearly explained. Additionally, some clients can be so set on their own choice that they are unable to take on board any other options. This paper looks into the implications of this triple bind and how it can be managed to provide the best care possible for the client..

Scene 17 (10m 6s)

[Audio] There are multiple underlying factors which contribute to the constraints faced by individuals in the process of receiving person-centred contraceptive care. These constraints are often born from the attribution of risk to individuals, creating a "triple bind" which can limit their access to the best possible care. Biomedicalisation has also been identified as a major contributor to this process, as it has a tendency to single out people based on age, wealth, and ethnicity..

Scene 18 (10m 36s)

[Audio] This paper's research illuminates how limits on both sides, combined with risks and misconceptions, can give rise to a triple bind that limits effective person-centred contraceptive care. Discursive unequal footing between patient and provider lies at the core of this dilemma, with the provider's inclination regularly buttressed by the language of efficacy and results. This then leads to medical paternalism, in which the provider's opinion on the most effective method is deemed to be in the patient's best interest rather than an approach that puts the patient in the driver's seat of their own care..

Scene 19 (11m 10s)

[Audio] Contraceptive care is hindered by the threefold burden of limitations, risks, and misapprehensions. This paper proposes that facilities help give individuals power of choice. Moreover, it claims that there are issues with the prevalent discourse on the effectuality of contraceptive actions. This paper also looks into the convictions that are made around the success of particular contraceptive techniques, particularly long-acting reversible contraception (LARC). It investigates the various levels on which these assumptions take place, such as provider-level and macro levels, as well as policies and regulations..

Scene 20 (11m 50s)

[Audio] We focus on how power imbalances can lead to constraints, risk, and misunderstandings, forming a triple bind which obstructs person-centred contraceptive care. Our research seeks to comprehend how power imbalances exist and how they are made and perpetuated, with the ultimate goal of making meaningful change in the near future..

Scene 21 (12m 11s)

Thanks for listeni. [email protected] https://www.tracymorison.com/contraceptive-study.

Scene 22 (12m 22s)

[Audio] Research found that a combination of constraints, risk, and misunderstandings can greatly hinder person-centred contraceptive care. This creates a difficult situation for healthcare providers and can leave patients feeling like their individual needs are not considered. This paper underscores the value of developing a trusting relationship between providers and patients to ensure that patients can access the best contraceptive care possible..