[Audio] All the Wrong Moves – Case Study by group 6. 

Scene 1

Presented by Group 6: Amit Ranjan (EDPDGCXO-3101) Jitendra Tanwar (EDPDGCXO-3090) Niraj Sharan (EDPDGCXO-3094) Rama Krishna Vuppala (EDPDGCXO-3013) Subramania ATHITHAN Rajendran  (EDPDGCXO-3054)

[Audio] In this presentation, we will delve into the Harvard Business Review case study, "All the Wrong Moves." This case explores the challenges faced by Nutrorim, a company in the sports supplement industry, due to its flawed decision-making process. We will analyze the missteps Nutrorim made, the consequences they faced, and the opportunity this crisis presented for the company to improve.. 

Scene 2

All the Wrong Moves A Case Study of Decision-Making at Nutrorim

[Audio] Nutrorim's story began brightly. Their flagship product, ChargeUp, captured the market's attention, leading to impressive growth for the company. Don Rifkin, the CEO, believed in a democratic approach to decision-making, encouraging participation from various departments.. 

Scene 3

Nutrorim, a Minneapolis-based company, enjoyed significant success with its organic sports supplement, ChargeUp. The product gained national attention, propelling the company's growth. CEO Don Rifkin fostered a collaborative and inclusive decision-making culture.

[Audio] To capitalize on ChargeUp's success, Nutrorim launched a new version: ChargeUp with Lipitrene. Lipitrene, a novel ingredient, promised enhanced performance benefits.. 

Scene 4

To capitalize on ChargeUp's success, Nutrorim launched a new version: ChargeUp with Lipitrene. Lipitrene, a novel ingredient, promised enhanced performance benefits. High expectations surrounded the new product launch.

[Audio] Nutrorim's dream run hit a roadblock when the Minnesota Department of Health contacted them about consumer complaints. Several users of ChargeUp with Lipitrene reported gastrointestinal distress. This news triggered a crisis within Nutrorim. Management had a crucial decision to make - recall the product or gamble on its safety, potentially jeopardizing the company's reputation.. 

Scene 5

Shortly after launch, the Minnesota Department of Health contacted Nutrorim regarding gastrointestinal issues reported by ChargeUp with Lipitrene users. This news sent shockwaves through the company, raising concerns about product safety and potential PR nightmares. Management had to make a critical decision: recall the product or risk damaging the brand's reputation.

[Audio] Nutrorim, under intense pressure and lacking clear direction, opted for a recall of ChargeUp with Lipitrene. A public statement was released acknowledging the reported problems and announcing the recall. Fortunately, a stroke of luck intervened. A further investigation by the health department identified the culprit as a contaminated smoothie bar at a local gym, exonerating Nutrorim.. 

Scene 6

Facing mounting pressure and uncertainty, Nutrorim decided to recall ChargeUp with Lipitrene. A public statement was issued, acknowledging the reported issues and announcing the recall. Fortunately, a follow-up investigation by the health department revealed the cause of the illnesses to be a contaminated smoothie bar at a local gym, exonerating Nutrorim.

[Audio] Nutrorim's open and inclusive decision-making culture became a hurdle during the crisis. The leadership team presented a divided front. Steve Ford, head of R&D, vehemently defended the product's safety based on internal testing. The PR and legal departments, however, pushed for a recall to minimize potential damage. Don Rifkin, caught in the middle, was unable to provide decisive leadership. There are frustration and conflicts in top management. CEO is not asking right set of questions on right time to right set of people. Too much navel gazing at the company. 

Scene 7

Nutrorim's management team displayed frustration and conflicting views during the crisis meeting. The R&D head, Steve Ford, adamantly defended the product's safety based on testing data.  The PR and legal departments taken quick decisions and advocated for a recall to mitigate potential damage without proper investigation. CEO Don Rifkin struggled to steer the discussion and make a definitive decision. CEO is not asking right set of questions on right time with right set of people Nutrorim had taken several flawed decision in past as well. Recent purchase of Depencit stocks without validating credibility of its CEO Mr.Cummings whereas Don should have trusted his committee member. It shows his inability to view facts and poor judgement CEO is applying friendly and democratic traits more than professional attitude.  Too much navel-gazing at the company as pointed by Nora

[Audio] Let's look in to the solutions we could propose in this scenario. CEO must ask right set of questions to create healthy dynamics, more cross-functional collaboration which would lead to take right decisions. Need to reshape management team structure and listen to everyone's concerns openly without any hesitations. Building trust with employees and teams is important. A proper policy and procedures should be defined to stream line the process. CEO should empower right people and let their voice heard, rearrange teams, enhance skills. CEO must maintain professionalism and have standards that would resonate across everyone working in the company
Innovation should not be at the cause of damage to the business. 

Scene 8

CEO must ask right set of questions to create healthy dynamics, more cross-functional collaboration which would lead to take right decisions on right time Need to reshape management team structure and listen to everyone’s concerns openly without any hesitations top to bottom. Building trust with employees and teams is important for success A proper policy and procedures should be defined to stream line the process. It which would have avoided scenarios like recall of ChargeUp upgraded version and purchase of Depencit stocks  CEO should empower right people and let their voice heard, rearrange teams, enhance skills  Be friendly but not friends. CEO must maintain professionalism and have standards that would resonate across everyone working in the company Innovation should not be at the cause of damage to the business

[Audio] To summarize, to address current potential issues, Nutrorim may need to conduct a comprehensive review of its business practices, market positioning, supply chain management, and internal operations. CEO must come up with engaging right set of questions to take right decisions. By identifying and addressing the underlying causes of recurring problems, Nutrorim can develop more effective strategies for sustainable growth and success.. 

Scene 9

To summarize, to address current potential issues, Nutrorim may need to conduct a comprehensive review of its business practices, market positioning, supply chain management, and internal operations. CEO must come up with engaging right set of questions to take right decisions. By identifying and addressing the underlying causes of recurring problems, Nutrorim can develop more effective strategies for sustainable growth and success.

All the Wrong Moves – Case Study

All the Wrong Moves – Case Study by group 6

avatar

In this presentation
 we will delve into the Harvard Business Review case study
 "All the Wrong Moves." This case explores the challenges faced by Nutrorim
 a company in the sports supplement industry
 due to its flawed decision-making process. We will analyze the missteps Nutrorim made
 the consequences they faced
 and the opportunity this crisis presented for the company to improve.

Nutrorim's story began brightly. Their flagship product
 ChargeUp
 captured the market's attention
 leading to impressive growth for the company. Don Rifkin
 the C-E-O
 believed in a democratic approach to decision-making
 encouraging participation from various departments.

To capitalize on ChargeUp's success
 Nutrorim launched a new version: ChargeUp with Lipitrene. Lipitrene
 a novel ingredient
 promised enhanced performance benefits.

Nutrorim's dream run hit a roadblock when the Minnesota Department of Health contacted them about consumer complaints. Several users of ChargeUp with Lipitrene reported gastrointestinal distress. This news triggered a crisis within Nutrorim. Management had a crucial decision to make  recall the product or gamble on its safety
 potentially jeopardizing the company's reputation.

Nutrorim
 under intense pressure and lacking clear direction
 opted for a recall of ChargeUp with Lipitrene. A public statement was released acknowledging the reported problems and announcing the recall. Fortunately
 a stroke of luck intervened. A further investigation by the health department identified the culprit as a contaminated smoothie bar at a local gym
 exonerating Nutrorim.

Nutrorim's open and inclusive decision-making culture became a hurdle during the crisis. The leadership team presented a divided front. Steve Ford
 head of R&D
 vehemently defended the product's safety based on internal testing. The PR and legal departments
 however
 pushed for a recall to minimize potential damage. Don Rifkin
 caught in the middle
 was unable to provide decisive leadership. There are frustration and conflicts in top management. C-E-O is not asking right set of questions on right time to right set of people. Too much navel gazing at the company

Let's look in to the solutions we could propose in this scenario. C-E-O must ask right set of questions to create healthy dynamics
 more cross-functional collaboration which would lead to take right decisions. Need to reshape management team structure and listen to everyone's concerns openly without any hesitations. Building trust with employees and teams is important. A proper policy and procedures should be defined to stream line the process. C-E-O should empower right people and let their voice heard
 rearrange teams
 enhance skills. 
CEO must maintain professionalism and have standards that would resonate across everyone working in the company
Innovation should not be at the cause of damage to the business

To summarize
 to address current potential issues
 Nutrorim may need to conduct a comprehensive review of its business practices
 market positioning
 supply chain management
 and internal operations. C-E-O must come up with engaging right set of questions to take right decisions. By identifying and addressing the underlying causes of recurring problems
 Nutrorim can develop more effective strategies for sustainable growth and success.